Taste Real Flavor, Cut Just for You

Shop Custom-Cut Meats, Deli Specialties, and Authentic Italian Ingredients

Thick ribeye steaks with heavy marbling

Where Craft Meets Quality

Step into a world where old-school craftsmanship and premium flavor go hand in hand. At Monahan Meats, we bring New York’s finest cuts and authentic Italian staples to your neighborhood. We offer:

  • A simple illustration of a steak with a bone.

    Hand-selected fresh meats cut to order

  • Icon of a covered food serving dome.

    Imported Italian cheeses and cured specialties

  • A stylized red mortar and pestle icon.

    Smoked and deli meats sliced on request

  • Minimalist red dining set icon with plate, fork, and knife.

    Specialty seasonings and food accessories

More Than a Butcher Shop

We’re not just selling food—we’re serving up a community experience. Here's what makes us different:

  • A maroon checkmark inside a circle with a shadow.

    Custom butcher services tailored to your needs

  • A maroon checkmark inside a circle with a shadow.

    An ever-growing menu of fresh sandwiches and deli fare

  • A maroon checkmark inside a circle with a shadow.

    A local shop atmosphere where service matters

  • A maroon checkmark inside a circle with a shadow.

    Trusted by families and small businesses across the neighborhood

Various cheeses displayed on a wooden surface.

Let’s Get in Touch

Have a question about a product, need a custom order, or just want to say hello? Visit us in-store, give us a call, or drop a message through our website.

What Our Customers Are Saying